As an early-career teacher, there were people who made some real contributions to my classroom’s culture and instruction. Obviously, some were
teacher coaches and
mentors who I have written about previously. Others, were residents of the southwest Philadelphia community where I started my career.
State Senator Anthony H. Williams, who has been recognized as
a 2017 Champion for Charters, was one of those community members. Every year, the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools recognizes the local, state and federal elected officials who lead the charge to give parents and students better public schools and the freedom to choose the school that works best for them. I remember as a
fledgling teacher, Sen. Williams, whose mother was a public school teacher, would visit my class to speak with my students and encourage me. His support and encouragement was extremely beneficial. He shared his experiences as a Black student in the very neighborhood I was working in. He connected me with community leaders and engaged our students in a plethora of opportunities. He advocated for children, youth, and communities. While today, people myopically view Sen. Williams as only a charter supporter, my direct experience has been that he supports
all of Pennsylvania’s children. He supported
Turner Middle School, which was a traditional public school
and he supports charters that are doing right by kids and communities. He supports what works for kids. Period. And, while many politicians hypocritically take stances against school choice for Black families, they wholeheartedly exercise school choice for themselves. Sen. Williams remembered his own family exercising school choice and he is not wont to neglect his responsibility to other people’s children when he benefitted from positive school experiences and options. It is always great to see when politicians don't abuse their privilege by forgetting how desperate families are for
school choice. Sen. Williams’ passion for school choice is well-documented. His advocacy is for children and choice. But, he also
calls out the hypocrisy of many of our politicians and policy makers.
I am exhausted by our time spent on beating up on a type of school. Why are we not focusing upon good schools?
Maybe I missed the moment when, in the district, that before charters existed, before we were broke, that the schools were great. Two-hundred-and-fifty-thousand students were in existence in Philadelphia County before charter schools showed up, before we went broke. We need to be honest. These children are suffering. These families out here are suffering. And we’re pandering to one group versus the other, and I refuse to do that. Charters, publics, magnets, all of them should be a part of the public school experience, and we need to stop beating up on one type and face the facts: We need fix them all and fund them all. A third of the district is charter…that’s not born out of a desire to desert public education. It’s born out of a desire to find an experience for one’s child.
And all of us have to confess publicly that if you don’t have a good school in your neighborhood, you have a right to find a good one. Charters are just one option. They’re not a silver bullet. Not every one’s excellent. But guess what? Not every neighborhood one is a great school, either. We need to judge the quality of a child’s experience, allow the money completely for a public experience, to drive what we in Philadelphia know is necessary.
It will keep people in Center City and in my part of the neighborhood in Philadelphia.
This is the Sen. Williams I met as a classroom teacher. Twenty-two years later, when we wanted to launch
The Fellowship: Black Male Educators for Social Justice, Sen. Williams was one of the first people we reached out to. His involvement, engagement, and commitment to public education made him an ideal community and civic leader for our group to engage. Congratulations, Sen. Williams for being recognized as a 2017 Champions for Charters during
National Charter Schools Week!
An original version of this post appeared on Philly's 7th Ward.
Sharif El-Mekki is the Founder and CEO of
the Center for Black Educator Development. The Center exists to ensure there will be equity in the recruiting, training, hiring, and retention of quality educators that reflect the cultural backgrounds and share common socio-political interests of the students they serve. The Center is developing a ...